IMDb’s Top 5 and 5 Worst Procedural Crime Shows of All Time

Most procedural crime episodes revolve around characters that are assigned to solve a new crime each episode. These characters can be law enforcement officers but they also can be ordinary citizens with special skills. There may be a common story that links each episode, but the main focus is always on the new cases.

Procedural crime shows have been very popular over the years with American television viewers. Many of these shows have lasted at least ten seasons. Many spinoffs were also created from the best procedurals. These are the most popular and least-rated procedural crime shows, according to IMDb ratings.

10 Best: Chicago P.D. (8.1)

Chicago. now part of the huge Chicago franchise. It debuted on January 8, 2014, as a replacement for Chicago Fire on NBC. It was created in a spinoff of the Chicago Fire. It follows the operations of Chicago’s 21st District police officers and intelligence officers under Detective Sergeant Hank Voight (Jason Beghe).

It has enjoyed a huge audience, with an average of 10,000,000 viewers per season. Chicago P.D. Also, the creation of another spinoff called Chicago Justice was a result.

9 Worst: Mrs. Columbo (5.8)

A change in titles can often be a sign of trouble, and this is exactly what happened with the procedural. The original name of the 1980s procedural was Mrs. Columbo was first known as Mrs. She was a journalist so the name was changed to Kate Loves A Mystery.

Columbo’s wife was the focus of the series. Kate enjoyed solving difficult cases for the news media. She tried to be a better mom to her daughter at the same time.

8 Best: Criminal Minds (8.1).

Crime Minds aired fifteen seasons due to its outstanding ratings. It aired from September 22, 2005, through February 19, 2020. The series featured FBI criminal profilers working under the Behavioral Analysis Unit (BAU). The majority of cases were about serial killers.

Three spinoffs were born from the show’s success. Criminal Minds averaged 12 million viewers for its nine first seasons. The viewership numbers dropped to 6,000,000 by the 15th and final season. It was a great time to close it.

7 Worst: CSI Cyber (5.4).

After only two seasons, the fourth show in the CSI franchise had been canceled. The show was not well received by the audience despite having a solid cast, including Bow Wow and Patricia Arquette.

The series was about a group of FBI Special Agents who investigated high-level cybercrimes that were committed by ordinary citizens in North America. The team was led by Avery Ryan, Deputy Director. The series scored 35% on Rotten Tomatoes.

6 Best: Bosch (8.4)

Bosch is loved by more than just viewers. critics also love it. Every season of the procedural has received a 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes since Season 2. Six seasons of, the Amazon Prime series, have been released to date. This brings the total number of episodes to 60. Recently, it was announced that the seventh season would be the last.

The series centers on Harry Bosch, an LAPD detective facing trial for the murder of a serial killer. He is a relentless detective in LAPD who works tirelessly to solve new cases every day, even though his case is advancing.

5 Worst: Holby blue (5.4).

After the huge success of the medical drama Holby City, the production team decided to create a spinoff called Casualty. It didn’t go so badly either. The producers realized that the audience needed more Holby. They created the procedural Holby Blue to be part of the larger Holby Universe.

Ratings were terrible this time. Even though the show featured talented actresses like Kacey Ainsworth or Zoe Lucker, there was no audience. The lack of original cases to solve could be the reason. After several episodes that received poor ratings and reviews, Episode 20 was canceled.

4 Best: Homicide-Life On The Street (8.5).

This ’90s police procedural is unlike any other. The Street provided an inside look at the complicated police work of a Baltimore homicide unit. The series was centered around Detective John Munch, Luitenant. Al Giardello, Det. Meldrick Lewis.

Although the procedural was originally based on the book Homicide: A Year in the Killing Streets, later seasons had their own life. During its tenure, the show was nominated three times for Emmys. Nielsen ratings show that each episode averaged at most 8 million viewers.

3 Worst: True Justice (4.7).

Although Steven Seagal is a well-known action star, almost all of his movies and Popular TV Show have not received favorable reviews from critics or fans. It’s amazing, considering that he has more than 70 movies under his belt.

Seagal tried to emulate Chuck Norris in 2011 by appearing on a TV show as Elijah Kane. He is the leader of the Special Investigation Unit, a Seattle task force. Seagal wrote all episodes. This was the same Seagal who had written many of his movies. True Justice lasted only two seasons.

2 Best: Brooklyn Nine-Nine (8.8)

While procedurals tend not to treat crime with as much seriousness as it deserves, Brooklyn Nine injects humor to great effect. Jake Peralta, a friendly NYPD detective who works in Brooklyn’s 99th Precinct, is the focus of the series.

Terry Crews plays Seargent Terry Jeffords. Fans also love rooting for the brilliantly comedic characters. Critics have praised the series highly.

1 Worst: Cop rock (4.3).

TV Guide placed Cop Rock 8 on its list of “50 Most Disappointing TV Shows”. The show’s failure may have been due to too many ambitions. The producers attempted to make every episode a musical, even though it was procedural. The show had contradictory themes because of this.

After only 11 episodes, ABC canceled Cop Rock. Some scenes featured gangsters singing and dancing while being detained by police. The cast and crew performed a closing song together in the final episode. This was the perfect way to close such a controversial show.